股东代表诉讼中的比例赔偿原则

Principle of Pro-rata Recovery Rationale in Shareholder derivative Action

成果信息
DC信息
传播影响力
本库下载频次:
本库浏览频次:
CNKI下载频次:0

归属学者：

曹兴权

归属院系：

民商法学院（知识产权学院）

作者：

曹兴权1 ;赵志浩

摘要：

股东代表诉讼制度的完善应关注胜诉利益的合理分配,在坚持胜诉利益当然全额归属于公司的全额赔偿原则基础的同时,有必要在控股股东滥用权利侵害公司利益且全额赔偿原则难以实现公平的场合例外地引入向股东赔偿部分利益的比例赔偿原则。作为异态的比例赔偿原则,应限于案涉公司面临清算、实施损害公司利益行为的主体为控股股东或兼具控股股东身份以及部分股东默认或批准了不法行为等有限的情况,并以法院具体利益衡量为必要前提。在操作时,应当以侵权主体的全部赔偿金为基数按控股股东之外的其他股东所持股比例计算各股东可以获得分配的数额,并且有权参与分配的股东在分配时应具有股东资格。

出版日期：

2020-06-20

学科：

经济法学; 诉讼法学

提交日期：

2020-07-31

引用参考：

曹兴权;赵志浩. 股东代表诉讼中的比例赔偿原则[J]. 时代法学,2020(03):19-29.

  • dc.title
  • 股东代表诉讼中的比例赔偿原则
  • dc.contributor.author
  • 曹兴权;赵志浩
  • dc.contributor.author
  • CAO Xing-quan;ZHAO Zhi-hao;Civil and Commercial Law School of Southwest University of Political Science and Law
  • dc.contributor.affiliation
  • 西南政法大学民商法学院
  • dc.publisher
  • 时代法学
  • dc.publisher
  • Presentday Law Science
  • dc.identifier.year
  • 2020
  • dc.identifier.issue
  • 03
  • dc.identifier.volume
  • v.18;No.101
  • dc.identifier.page
  • 19-29
  • dc.date.issued
  • 2020-06-20
  • dc.subject
  • 股东代表诉讼;胜诉利益分配;全额赔偿原则;比例赔偿原则
  • dc.subject
  • shareholder derivative action;distribution method of winning suit interests;principle of full compensation;principle of pro-rata recovery rationale
  • dc.description.abstract
  • 股东代表诉讼制度的完善应关注胜诉利益的合理分配,在坚持胜诉利益当然全额归属于公司的全额赔偿原则基础的同时,有必要在控股股东滥用权利侵害公司利益且全额赔偿原则难以实现公平的场合例外地引入向股东赔偿部分利益的比例赔偿原则。作为异态的比例赔偿原则,应限于案涉公司面临清算、实施损害公司利益行为的主体为控股股东或兼具控股股东身份以及部分股东默认或批准了不法行为等有限的情况,并以法院具体利益衡量为必要前提。在操作时,应当以侵权主体的全部赔偿金为基数按控股股东之外的其他股东所持股比例计算各股东可以获得分配的数额,并且有权参与分配的股东在分配时应具有股东资格。
  • dc.description.abstract
  • The improvement of the shareholder derivative action should not only focus on the construction of procedural rules, but also how to distribute the winning suit interests of shareholder derivative action in order to meet the original intention of this system. With the common occurrence of controlling shareholders' participation in the company's operations and damage to the interests of the company, if continuing to adhere to the principle of full compensation that winning suit interests shall always belong to the company, it cannot truly protect the interests of the company and the interests of small and medium shareholders. The principle of pro-rata recovery rationale should be adopted in order to forms a binary distribution method of winning suit interests in shareholder derivative action. In specific shareholder derivative action cases, pro-rata recovery rationale should be used in the distribution of the winning suit interest when the company involved in the case is facing liquidation, the subject of acts that harm the company's interests is the controlling shareholder or concurrently controlling shareholder status, and some shareholders default or approve the wrongdoing. It means that the entity that implements the behavior that damages the interests of the company shall directly pay the entire compensation to the shareholders with damaged interests according to the shareholding ratio.
  • dc.identifier.CN
  • 43-1431/D
  • dc.identifier.issn
  • 1672-769X
  • dc.identifier.if
  • 0.341
  • dc.subject.discipline
  • D922.291.91;D925.1
回到顶部